City Looking Into TDC Funding for the Duval Loop 

Streets for People | Friends of Car-Free Key West & Duval Street/Historic Downtown | Chris Hamilton |October 3, 2026 | Substack | KONK Life | Short-version crossposted at The Keys Citizen

Good news for our downtown. The City is beginning to look into using TDC monies to fund the Duval Loop, which has been “suspended” since December 31, 2025, and received no money to bring it back in the budget year that just began October 1.

At the September 10 City budget hearing City Manager Brian Barroso told the commissioners that “we are unable to do TDC funding for the Loop.” Mayor Sam Kaufman asked, “Do we have a written opinion about that…?” And just this week the City’s Director of Finance, Christina Bervaldi, told us she has requested a definitive written opinion from the Monroe County Attorney’s Office on whether all or part of the Loop’s operating costs could qualify, what the City would need to show, and what the process would be.

Progress! And good on Ms. Bervaldi for pursuing it.

This matters because using Tourist Development Council (TDC) dollars to cover all or much of the Duval Loop, not only makes our downtown economy run better, but allows the use of other dedicated sources the Mayor has asked staff to explore, such as higher parking fees, to go to more frequent, longer-running service on the new Island Hopper that will replace Key West Rides on-demand and Workforce Express in the coming months.

Let’s walk through what the County Attorney has already said on this subject, the evidence the City already has to make the case this is a tourist-serving route, and why this matters for the whole system and not just the Loop.

Original map left and most current version right. Note all the tourist attractions on each map.

Monroe County Has Established TDC Money for the Loop Is Indeed Possible

To their credit the County has been working on the issue of TDC funds for tourist-serving transit since January. When County Administrator Christine Hurley heard that City Commissioner Monica Haskell had put a discussion item on the January 6 City Commission meeting regarding supporting tourist tax funds for tourist-serving transit, she began looking into the issue.

Ms. Hurley asked Senior Assistant County Attorney Christine Limbert-Barrows about using tourist tax funds for tourist serving transit. Ms. Limbert-Barrows quoted a Florida Attorney General’s Opinion AGO 2017-06 that says tourist tax money can’t fund “a transit system in general,” but can fund “specific transportation services that are clearly intended to attract tourism.” She added that a study is not required under §125.0104(5)(a)3. A study is only required under the “public facilities” category.

Ms. Hurley asked the Attorney, “If no study is required, then how do you verify the transit service is for tourist/promotion of tourist vs. general public?”

Ms. Limbert-Barrows responded it would normally go through a grant application process, but as the County has no grant process for transportation, the TDC would look to the City to provide ridership information, marketing to tourists and the stops at tourist resorts and attractions.

At the time, County stuff was looking for money for the Lower Keys Shuttle and Stock Island Transit. The County Attorney’s office made it clear to County management that TDC funds cannot be used on what are considered commuter routes.

If you look at the string of emails between the County Administrator and County Attorney’s office, you’ll find they also looked at a possible extra penny of bed tax. It would follow the same rules, so it could help tourist-serving service like the Loop but not commuter routes and it would need a voter referendum too. Perhaps we’ll explore this avenue at a later date.

Video saying: “The Duval Loop has multiple stops directly in front of our boutique hotels, making it a convenient mode of transportation around the island while staying with us at Historic Key West Inns! “Ride Free and Frequent”

A Quick Note About the County – City Contradiction

In our September 17 article, Another Year, No New Transit Money In the Keys, we discussed that at the County Budget hearing Administrator Hurley said the County Attorney’s Office – citing an attorney general opinion – found TDC money can’t fund general transit, but can fund transit that “would provide services directly to tourists.” 

At the City’s budget hearing the next day both the City Manager and Director of Finance told the Commissioners, no this couldn’t be done. But the Mayor had asked to see the written opinion. And we followed up with a request to see what the answer had been based on because of the County Attorney’s opinion.

In an email response Ms. Bervaldi wrote: “Because this question continues to arise, I have requested a definitive written opinion from the Monroe County Attorney’s Office specifically addressing whether all or a portion of the Duval Loop’s operating costs could qualify for TDC funding and, if so, what the City need to demonstrate or document in order for that funding to be considered.”

She continued that if a determination is made that the Duval Loop is an allowable use of TDC revenues, this would establish eligibility; it would not guarantee that the City would receive funding and that the City would need to go through the appropriate process.

Doing the Homework – How the City Already Has the Case for TDC Funds for the Loop

Assuming the County Attorney gives Ms. Bervaldi the same answer it gave to County management and commissioners, the City’s application for ongoing operating funds from the TDC would need to demonstrate the Loop was for tourists with ridership information, marketing materials and that the bus stops served resorts and attractions. The City already has all the information; it just needs to gather them up and make the case. Let’s walk through those:

A. Where the Duval Loop Goes (stops at resorts and attractions)

The Florida Attorney General Opinion AGO 2017-06 says in referring to tourist-serving systems that would qualify:

 “Such transportation services should involve routes and schedules addressing the specific needs of tourists, and might include, for example, a shuttle connecting hotels and motels with county tourist attractions.”

The City’s own Loop map labels about 20 destinations along the route: Mallory Square, the Hemingway Home, Southernmost Point, the Lighthouse, Mel Fisher Museum, the Historic Seaport, Harbor Walk, Turtle Cannery, Truman Waterfront, the Cruise Ship Docks, the Ferry Terminal, the Gay Key West Visitors Center, Mile Marker 0, Custom House, the Studios, the Tropic, and several theaters.

Within 500 feet, or about a block, of the Loop’s last route we found at least 50 hotels, inns, guesthouses and B&Bs. 

B. Who the Duval Loop Is Sold To (marketing to tourists)

From the beginning the Duval Loop was planned for and marketed to tourists. I should know because I was the City’s Bicycle and Pedestrian Coordinator at the time in 2017. But the evidence is in the City’s records, not my memory. Here are a few items the City can build on:

  • The bus wrap: “Ride Free and Frequent,” “Get there. Have fun. Get back.,” and a route map on the side – all aimed at making it easy for tourists to understand.
  • The bus stop flags carry the same messages.
  • “Park It and Forget It”: “Now that you’re parked… catch the free and frequent Duval Loop.” It’s aimed at visitors who drove in.
  • “Your Free Ride to All the Fun!”: shops, bars, restaurants, “quirky stuff that make Key West famous.”
  • The partner program (archived carfreekeywest.com): “Over 75 hospitality and retail businesses signed up to be partners in the first 3 months.” Each received a free Partner Kit and an on-site consult, to help “locals and visitors get even more out of our island paradise.”
  • The kit contents: the Car-Free map, the Loop brochure (“…enjoy Key West stress-free!”), safety tips, stickers, a bottle and a bike light.
  • Key West Weekly, February 24, 2017, in her story Hays Blinckmann said, “The media push will stretch far and wide, from ferry terminals to airports to hotels and bike shops, in hopes tourists will keep their cars parked or opt out of one altogether.” And as I told the paper then, the Lodging Association, Business Guild, Chamber and Attractions associations were all supportive. 
  • In an early planning study and survey documented by Mary Bishop in a USF Journal of Transportation Demand Management (2019) report, her 2016 survey found 66% of visitors arrived by car and 27% said a car was their main way of getting around once here. Drivers rated free public transit as the top incentive to leave that car at home. She recommended a circulator with waits of 15 minutes or less. 

The Duval Loop was built, branded and sold to help visitors get around downtown, and the City’s own materials show it.

C. Do Tourists Ride the Duval Loop? (ridership information)

The first year of service for the Duval Loop in FY18 saw 317,320 rides. The next year in FY19  saw 331,603. We haven’t been able to, as of yet, track down actual survey data on the breakdown of who they were. However, in a May 5, 2020, City Commission meeting discussing instituting a $1 fare on tourists riding the Loop while locals with an ID would be exempted, then Transit Director Rod Delostrinos (File #20-5655, about 1:00:06) says that while the City didn’t capture local vs. tourist numbers “it looks about 80% tourist and 20% local.” At the same meeting planners told Commissioners they expected that new $1 fare would bring in about $380,000 – that’s a lot of tourists. 

In a January, 2026 email to County Administrator Christine Hurley Mr. Delostrinos, now an Assistant City Manager said they didn’t have a hard mechanism for the counts but “Anecdotally, the ridership has been 90% tourist and 10% local.” So, the same official, six years apart, says between 80 and 90 percent. 

The legal test is “one of its main purposes,” so locals riding doesn’t disqualify it. And it would be nice if someone at the City can find actual survey data to back this up. 

Why It Matters and What Happens Next

A Florida Attorney General Opinion laid out how tourist tax dollars could be used for tourist serving transit. The County Attorney laid out the criteria in ridership, marketing and bus stops – where it goes – to meet that threshold. We think there’s plenty of evidence for making the case that the Duval Loop is primarily tourist serving transit and as such should indeed be eligible.

The Mayor asked to see the opinion. The Director of Finance has now requested a definitive written opinion from the County Attorney and once received by the City the process for applying for TDC funds for the operation should commence immediately so all of the i’s are dotted and the t’s are crossed well before any TDC, County or City deadlines for the next cycle of funding in FY28. The County and TDC should open the door, whether that means adding transit to an existing funding round or creating one.

This matters for two broad reasons. First, downtown Key West is the golden goose that keeps our local economy going. And that economy is a visitor economy. The Duval Loop, when it is “Free and Frequent” ensures that visitors leave their cars in the garage and don’t clog our streets – marring the experience that brings people here – and don’t fight with locals for parking. Everything works better when visitors have an easy and free option to explore all there is to offer in downtown. We’ve heard of tourists who don’t get to other parts of downtown without it. It just makes everything work better.

And the other reason is that if we can use tourist money for the Loop then any new dedicated funds can be used to make transit for the locals better. The new Island Hopper that’s scheduled to replace the Key West Rides on-demand and Workforce Express routes with a big loop around the island will have service every 45-minutes from 6 am to 8pm. Imagine 30 or even 15-minute service that goes until 2 am. Taking care of the Loop means new found funding goes to improving everything else.

Bringing back the whole ethos of “Get there. Have fun. Get back.” is what our island is all about and we’ll all be better off with the return of a robust Duval Loop for our downtown.

# # #

Chris Hamilton is the founder of Friends of Car-Free Key West & Duval Street/Historic Downtown, a local advocacy group championing sustainable mobility and vibrant public spaces. Subscribe to the blog and follow on Facebook, Twitter, and Substack for updates. All stories are cross posted at KONK Life News. Originally from Washington, D.C., Chris spent over two decades leading nationally acclaimed initiatives in transit, biking, walking, and smart growth for Arlington County, VA’s DOT. Since moving to Key West in 2015, he has embraced a car-free lifestyle downtown, dedicating his time to non-profits and community projects. Explore all Streets for People column.

1 Comments on “City Looking Into TDC Funding for the Duval Loop ”

Leave a Reply